[Nettime-bold] Re: <nettime> The Napsterisation of Everything

[Bill Spornitz <spornitz@mts.net>]

At 1:18 AM +0000 11/28/01, richard barbrook wrote:
>The Napsterisation of Everything: a review of John Alderman, Sonic Boom:
>Napster, P2P and the battle for the future of music, Fourth Estate, London
>2001.
>
>Richard Barbrook

snip!

>Unlike earlier forms of youthful rebellion, peer-to-peer computing is a
>direct threat to the economics of the music industry. Despite the rapid
>changes in musical tastes over the decades, the fundamentals of its
>business structure have remained the same. Musicians are contracted to make
>recordings. Music is sold on bits of plastic to consumers. Copyright laws
>ensure that no one can distribute recordings without paying their owners.
>Everyone supposedly benefits from this arrangement. Fans are offered a wide
>choice of many different types of music. Musicians are able to earn a
>living - and a few can become seriously rich. Small companies can survive
>by selling niche styles of music. Large corporations can own profitable
>music companies as part of their multi-media empires. Having recuperated
>successive cultural revolutions, this business structure appeared 
>to >beimmutable.

There's another side to this debate that is conveniently overlooked. 
Even the American Federation of Musicians (the *Union*) comes out 
strongly against file sharing, when it is not an understatement to 
say that the unauthorized reproduction of copyrighted musical works 
is an integral part of the multi-billion dollar live music industry.

In the ten years or so I played in the live *scene* I must have 
played thousands of songs by other artists (what we call *covers*) 
without any effort to compensate copyright holders. It might be 
foolish of me to admit to this, except that I am joined in this 
activity by millions of fellow musicians. Indeed, a large percentage 
of these cases, band leaders insist that arrangement specifics like 
sax solos be copied exactly from the recordings.


The song is a very powerful and efficient artifact. More than 
stopping file trading, what these people are trying to do is, 
essentially, defeat the overwhelming power of song. They will not 
succeed.

b

_______________________________________________
Nettime-bold mailing list
Nettime-bold@nettime.org
http://amsterdam.nettime.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/nettime-bold