[Nettime-bold] Re: [CI]: Re: [CPI-UA]: Reform Democracy for the Internet Age

["Michel J. Menou" <Michel.Menou@wanadoo.fr>]

Michael Gurstein's points are well taken.
Even without sticking to historical materialism, it is however useful to place
the debate about democracy, electronic or not, in a particular time, space and
context.
Direct democracy, or alledged forms of this, have shown throughout history their
limits. While it can work, to some extent, in small places among people who can
know each other and on specific issues, it can hardly apply to large
communities, especially if they are amorphous as Internet users worldwide for
instance.
Thus the issue is how to create legitimate and democratic bodies, structures,
intermediaires, etc. who can act as representatives for the many "virtual communities".
There is no doubt that the technology in itself is capable of tremendously
easing democratic processes. However what we have seen up to now too often is
the possibilty it offers to a few wired self-appointed gurus to monopolize the instrument and the
discourse. Institutional manipulation is not less exquisite when putting up an
odd electronic conference or consultation for a short while can be presented as
the basis for evidencing democratic approval of a proposal.
Of course, this is only the beginning and we have a long way to go and learn.
Let's hope it won't get us in some brave new (already!) world.
Michel



_______________________________________________
Nettime-bold mailing list
Nettime-bold@nettime.org
http://www.nettime.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/nettime-bold